This outcome tests whether you can tell raw data from processed information and name which attribute of good information a scenario breaches. The examiner likes it because each question gives a short scenario with one clear failing, and you must match it to the correct attribute.
The rule
Data is raw, unprocessed facts and figures. Information is data that has been processed (sorted, grouped, totalled) into a form that is meaningful and useful for decisions. Good information has these attributes: accurate, complete, cost-beneficial, user-targeted, relevant, authoritative (reliable source), timely, and easy to use. Pick the one attribute that the scenario's specific failing points to.
Worked example
Moorfield Cafe Ltd records 3,000 till entries in a month, each showing item, quantity and price. These entries are data.
The finance team groups them by product and totals them:
Coffee: 1,200 sales x $3 = $3,600
Cakes: 800 sales x $4 = $3,200
Sandwiches: 1,000 sales x $6 = $6,000
Total revenue = $12,800
This summary is information, because it has been processed and the owner can see that sandwiches earn the most.
Now suppose the owner is given a local demand figure from an unnamed website to estimate local demand. The figure may be information, but its authority is in doubt, because the source cannot be verified. If the owner receives all 3,000 entries instead of the summary, that is a user-targeting failing: too much detail and not easy to use.
Remember: detail is not the same as information; data becomes information only when it is processed into a meaningful form, and too much detail breaches the user-targeted and easy-to-use attribute.
Where candidates lose marks
Treating a long, detailed list as information because it is detailed, when it is raw data.
Choosing completeness when the real problem is information overload, which breaches the user-targeted and easy-to-use attribute.
Choosing timeliness or relevance for an unverified source, when the attribute in doubt is the authority of the source.
Try it: 4 questions
An analyst at Sunrise Solar Ltd, a solar panel installer, takes a market size figure from an anonymous internet forum post. She uses it in a sales forecast supporting a $2m investment decision. Which attribute of good information is in doubt, and what does this imply?
Answer: C. Good information should come from a reliable, authoritative source. A figure from an anonymous forum post cannot be verified, so the source is in doubt and the forecast built on it is questionable, which matters for a $2m decision. Option A is wrong because nothing in the scenario says the post is out of date, and being online does not make a figure old. Option B is wrong because a market size figure could well be relevant; the doubt is over where it came from. Option D is wrong because low cost is not the issue; the figure's reliability is.
Hope Trust operates a network of charity shops. Its head office holds a list of 5,000 till transactions for the month (item code, quantity and $ price). It also holds a summary showing sales revenue by product category for the month. Which of the following correctly identifies the data and the information?
Answer: B. Data is raw, unprocessed facts and figures. Information is data that has been processed so that it is meaningful to a user and useful for decisions. The 5,000 till transactions are raw records, so they are data. The category summary has been sorted, grouped and totalled, so it is information. Option A reverses the two: it treats detail as information, but detail alone is not processing. Option C is wrong because processing changes data into information. Option D is wrong because printing or reporting does not make something information; it must be processed and meaningful.
The managing director of Fenn Textiles Ltd, a textile mill, receives a 40-page monthly report listing every cost centre's detailed ledger codes. He says he cannot find the key points he needs for his decisions. Which attribute of good information is most clearly breached?
Answer: D. Good information should suit the needs of its user and be clear and easy to understand. A senior manager needs a concise summary of key points, not 40 pages of ledger-code detail. This is information overload, a breach of being user-targeted and easy to use. Option A is wrong because completeness means including everything needed, and too much detail is not the same as that. Option B is wrong because the problem is finding key points, not mistakes in the figures. Option C is wrong because nothing is said about delay.
Cloudly Ltd, a software subscription firm, is considering a reporting system that would cost $15,000 a year to run. Management estimates that better decisions made using it would save $9,000 a year. Which TWO of the following statements are correct?
Select the two that apply (each shows on its own).
Answer: A, B. Information should be worth more than it costs to produce. Here cost is $15,000 and benefit is $9,000, so cost exceeds benefit by $6,000 (15,000 - 9,000). The proposal fails the cost-benefit test and is not worthwhile on this basis. Option C is wrong because the failure comes from the $ comparison, and an estimate does not make the information inaccurate. Option D is wrong because it adds cost and benefit ($15,000 + $9,000 = $24,000) instead of netting them. Option E is wrong because it looks at the benefit alone and ignores the $15,000 cost.
1 more MA questions on this outcome, free for life
The full ACCA MA bank, mock exams and written questions marked against the scheme. Email only, no card, no trial.
What is the difference between data and information in management accounting?
Data is raw, unprocessed facts and figures, such as a list of till transactions. Information is data that has been processed into a meaningful form that helps a user make decisions, such as sales revenue by product category.
What are the attributes of good information in ACCA MA?
Good information is accurate, complete, cost-beneficial, user-targeted, relevant, authoritative, timely and easy to use. In a question, choose the attribute that matches the specific failing described.
Which attribute is breached if a manager gets a report that is too long?
The report breaches the user-targeted and easy-to-use attribute, because information overload stops the reader finding the key points. It is not a completeness problem, as completeness means including what is needed, not everything.