This outcome asks you to match a measure to the specific obstacle an SME faces: weak credit rating, lack of collateral, or inability to service debt. The examiner likes it because the scenario always signals the problem, and the right answer is the measure that fixes that problem.
The rule
Identify the obstacle first, then choose the measure. Supply chain finance: the bank pays invoices approved by a strong customer early, and the discount reflects the customer's credit risk, not the SME's. Government loan guarantee: the government covers part of the lender's loss on default, which substitutes for missing collateral, but the SME still owes the full debt. Business angels: equity with no fixed interest or dividend, often with management advice and contacts, suited to early-stage firms with negative cash flow and no security.
Worked example
Boxwell Ltd sells $100,000 of goods to a highly rated retailer on 90-day terms. Under a supply chain finance programme the retailer approves the invoice and the bank pays Boxwell on day 10 at an annual discount of 5%, based on the retailer's rating.
Days financed early = 90 - 10 = 80.
Discount = $100,000 x 5% x 80/365 = $1,096.
Cash received = $100,000 - $1,096 = $98,904.
If Boxwell's own overdraft costs 12% a year, the same 80 days would cost $100,000 x 12% x 80/365 = $2,630. The saving of about $1,534 arises because the price reflects the retailer's risk. Boxwell gets cash 80 days sooner and at lower cost.
Remember: the cost of supply chain finance follows the strong customer's credit risk, and a government loan guarantee protects the lender only, so the SME still owes the whole loan.
Where candidates lose marks
Choosing the option where the discount is priced on the SME's own credit rating, which removes the main benefit of supply chain finance.
Thinking a government guarantee reduces the amount the SME must repay, when it only covers the lender's default loss.
Recommending an overdraft, fixed-rate loan or stock market listing to an early-stage SME with negative cash flow and no security, instead of equity such as a business angel.
Try it: 3 questions
Boxwell Ltd, a small packaging maker, sells to a large, highly rated retailer on 90-day credit terms. Boxwell has cash-flow strain and a weak credit rating of its own. The retailer's bank offers a supply chain finance programme under which invoices approved by the retailer are paid to the supplier early, at a discount. Which of the following best explains why the programme eases Boxwell's financing problem and what drives the cost of the early payment?
Answer: C. In supply chain finance the bank funds invoices that the retailer has approved. The bank is mainly exposed to the retailer, which has a strong credit rating, so the discount rate reflects the retailer's risk and not the SME's. Boxwell gets cash soon after approval instead of waiting 90 days. Its financing cost is typically lower than it could achieve on its own, so its working capital strain eases.
Why the other options are wrong: - Option A is wrong because it prices the discount on the SME's own rating. That would remove the main benefit of the programme. - Option B is wrong because early payment is the whole point of the programme. Boxwell does not have to wait until the due date. - Option D is wrong because the programme accelerates the supplier's cash receipt. It does not lengthen the payment period, and a longer period would worsen Boxwell's cash position.
Helix Labs Co is a profitable, growing pharmaceutical testing laboratory. Its cash-flow forecasts are sound, but most of its value lies in staff expertise and it has few tangible assets. Its bank has declined a term loan because of insufficient collateral. The government runs a loan guarantee scheme under which it covers a proportion of any loss the lender suffers if the borrower defaults. Which of the following correctly describes how the scheme eases Helix Labs Co's financing problem?
Answer: A. The problem is the funding gap caused by a lack of collateral. The lender cannot recover enough from asset security if the SME defaults. A government guarantee covers a proportion of the lender's default loss. This replaces the missing security, so the bank can lend to a viable SME it would otherwise reject. The guarantee is between the government and the lender. The SME still owes the full debt and the interest.
Why the other options are wrong: - Option B is wrong because the guarantee protects the lender, not the borrower. The SME's repayment obligation is not reduced, and the government may seek recovery from it. - Option C is wrong because the scheme is a form of debt support. No equity is issued or injected, and the SME's gearing still rises. - Option D is wrong because the guarantee does not set interest rates. The lender may charge a lower margin because its risk is lower, but this is not a legal requirement, and the main effect is on availability of finance.
Aquasense Co is an early-stage technology SME that develops leak-detection sensors for water utilities. It has high growth potential but negative cash flow and no assets to offer as security. It cannot afford regular interest or dividend payments, and its owners would also value management advice. Which of the following is the most suitable source of finance?
Answer: D. Aquasense has no security and negative cash flow, so it cannot service debt and lenders will probably refuse. Equity is needed. A business angel invests equity, does not require fixed interest or regular dividends, and usually adds management experience, advice and contacts. This matches all of the SME's needs.
Why the other options are wrong: - Option A is wrong because an overdraft is short-term and repayable on demand. It is also unsuitable for long-term investment, and without security the bank is unlikely to offer one. - Option B is wrong because a loan requires fixed interest payments and repayment, which the company cannot afford, and it normally needs security. - Option C is wrong because a listing involves high flotation costs, ongoing regulatory and reporting burdens, and a track record that an early-stage company lacks. The apparent prestige and size of funds do not outweigh these.
0 more FM questions on this outcome, free for life
The full ACCA FM bank, mock exams and written questions marked against the scheme. Email only, no card, no trial.
How does supply chain finance help a small supplier?
The bank pays invoices that a large customer has approved before the due date, at a discount. Because the bank is exposed mainly to the customer's strong credit rating, the supplier gets cash sooner and usually at a lower cost than its own borrowing.
How does a government loan guarantee scheme ease SME financing problems?
The government covers a proportion of the lender's loss if the SME defaults. This replaces missing collateral, so the bank can lend to a viable business it would otherwise reject. The SME remains fully liable for the debt.
Why are business angels suitable for early-stage SMEs?
Angels provide equity, so there are no fixed interest or dividend payments, which suits a firm with negative cash flow and no security. They also often add management experience, advice and contacts.